Living Past Masters
| Lodge Key | |
| 36 | |
| 91 | |
| 98 | |
| * | |
| # | |
| Name | Master Year |
| William H Cross (36) | 1967 |
| Leland D Cobb Jr* (91) | 1969, 1980, 1989 |
| James W Oates (91) | 1970 |
| Chester A Clark Jr (98) | 1972 |
| William H Walter (91) | 1973, 1983 |
| Gordon C Willoughby Jr (98) | 1974 |
| Richard A Lewis (98) | 1977 |
| James S York* (98) | 1978 |
| Brian L Birch (98) | 1979 |
| Richard G Adams (91) | 1981 |
| Ira N Cameron (98) | 1981 |
| Floyd T Edwards (98) | 1982 |
| H Bradford Wylie (36) | 1982 |
| Leon M Barnard (98) | 1984, 1985 |
| Willem H M Hacken (36) | 1986 |
| Douglas D Barnard* (98) | 1987, 1997 |
| Donald R Skinner (36) | 1989 |
| F Kent Matlack (91) | 1992 |
| John E Pearson (98) | 1993 |
| Jeffery L Wayand (91) | 1993, 2004 |
| William E Bohman*# (36) | 1994, 1996 |
| Leo A Heinl (91) | 1994, 1995 |
| Erick J Baechle (36) | 1998 |
| James C Watkins (98) | 1999 |
| Richard R Jones Jr* (98) | 2000, 2002 |
| Randal R Davis (91) | 2001 |
| Robert H Everest* (36) | 2001, 2002 |
| Randy K Stuck (91) | 2002 |
| Theodore L Hasty* (98) | 2003, 2004 |
| Raymond D Smith (36) | 2003 |
| Kevin W Stuck (91) | 2003 |
| Robert D Hafner Sr (36) | 2004 |
2005
Consolidation of
St. Marks #36, St. Marks #91, and Hiram #98
into:
VALLEY LODGE #36
| Name | Master Year |
| Jeffery L Wayand | 2005 |
| Peter A Hermance | 2006 |
| Robert H Everest* | 2007, 2010, 2013 |
| Guy O Whelchel* | 2008, 2012 |
| Kevin W Stuck | 2009, 2018 |
| Donald R Skinner | 2011 |
| Paul W Holjes | 2014 |
| R James Wasz | 2015, 2016, 2017 |
| Seth B Brickman | 2019 |
| William C Gleason | 2020 |
| Michael D Hunter | 2021, 2022 |
| Nathaniel L Jillette | 2023 |